I just walked in that day and was like, ‘I really want to write an 80’s-sounding song,’” Kelley said. “Lindsay started playing that little synth part. When I left that day, I was like, ‘This feels ...

In their place were compact, polished songs that hurtled up the charts, taking the LPs with them. Every '80s album reached No. 1 on the U.K. charts, and after Duke, the next three Genesis LPs were ...